A judge has ruled that Grafton Thomas, whose stabbing attack at a Hanukkah celebration left Josef Neumann dead and motivated New York State to pass special ‘hate crimes’ legislation to deter such attacks, is not mentally fit to stand trial:
The 37-year-old Thomas was charged in the December 28 attack that left five people wounded. The most critically injured victim, Josef Neumann, 72, died of his wounds in late March, three months after the attack.
Federal prosecutors said Thomas targeted congregants celebrating the seventh night of Hanukkah at the Monsey home of Rabbi Chaim Rottenberg because of their Jewish faith.
Thomas has pleaded not guilty to attempted murder and other charges.
Judge Cathy Siebel wrote that Thomas should be committed to a treatment facility for no more than four months to determine if he can reach “the capacity to permit criminal proceedings to go forward against him.”
The ruling only applies to Thomas’ trial for federal hate crimes, noted AP.
Federal prosecutors have said Thomas had handwritten journals containing anti-Semitic comments and a swastika, and had researched Adolf Hitler’s hatred of Jews online.
One of the prosecutors has said in the past that if Neumann dies of his wounds, Thomas could face the death penalty.
Thomas’ attorney Michael Sussman has argued from the start that his client was not motivated by anti-Semitism and has struggled with mental illness for years.
So it appears that the killing of Josef Neumann by an insane Black man was not motivated by ‘antisemitism’ or ‘hate’ after all.
Does this mean that New York State will rescind their new draconian law named after Neumann that elevated ‘hate crimes’ to the status of domestic terrorism? Don’t hold your breath.
This case clearly demonstrates the absurdity of so-called ‘hate crime’ laws — people don’t attack or kill other people because they like them, but for a court to decide what is acceptable motivation for a crime and what is an ‘aggravating’ motivation based on what society deems ‘politically incorrect’ is a slippery slope that can never be judged fairly and impartially.
What matters is whether or not a crime was committed, not the political opinions of the person committing the crime.
Ironically, Jews have been pushing to make ‘antisemitism’ a form of mental illness — so that ‘antisemites’ can be deemed insane by a court and thrown away in mental hospitals.
Only someone who suffers from a mental illness would think that anyone who dislikes them is mentally ill.
What if an ‘antisemite’ like Grafton Thomas has a real unlying mental illness on top of his ‘antisemitism’?
Only a rabbi could possibly sort out that complicated legal conundrum.
Judaism is the wellspring and fountain of Bigotry and Hate.
Every form of hate is enumerated as fundamental to their beliefs.
For 3,500 years antiGENTILISM has been the glue binding Judaism
For 2,000 years antiCHRISTianity has been the Super Glue of Jewish HATE.
Jews have-to-have “antisemitism” to maintain their identity and cohesiveness.
antiGENTILISM is the problem. Cavemen did not sit around their caves:
GROK: “HEY, me hate Jews.”
HORG: “What a Jew?”
GROK: “Me not know …. but me hate”
HORG: ” We wait for Jew to come so we be mean to him”
Then non-Jews sat for tens of thousands of years waiting, waiting, waiting, for a Jew to come along, so we could all be mean for no reason.
So the perpetrator of the incident that precipitated a new ‘hate crime’ law isn’t even going to get charged with said crime because the basis for which this crime has now been determined to have been perpetrated does not fit the narrative of this law? There was a time when citizens turned into angry mobs over such things and tarred and feathered more than a few politicians…but now we cower in our homes, believing everything the one-eyed-screaming-rabbi tells us…
https://www.unz.com/ejones/black-frankenstein-turns-on-its-jewish-creators/
Good article.
Now they’ll use this case to claim all WN people and Christians are crazy and for their own protection, should be rounded up and put in FEMA camps, run by some Jew outfit.
The jews ALWAYS turn everything around and blame their enemies of the very things they themselves are guilty of. It is these jews who are mentally defective, yet they call their enemies “mentally ill.” I can’t wait for the world to turn on these devils.
I love it when the Jew’s weapons and tactics turn against him. His hubris always leads him to perdition.